Cast changes on Stargate Atlantis season 5 (spoilers, maybe)

[wraithfodder]

Not that anybody hasn't guessed half of it due to NBC/Universal's press release on Amanda Tapping going over to Sanctuary. But anyway, will stick it under the cut to be safe. 

In Joe Mallozzi's February 1st blog entry, he said:

As stated in the SciFi press release, Amanda will guest star on Atlantis’s fifth season - but the exact number of appearances by Colonel Carter will be wholly dependant on Amanda’s availability and the types of stories we have in the works. Still, Carter will be one of a number of familiar faces that will be popping up in the Pegasus Galaxy in season 5 - including a new commander. Remember way back, when I said we had considered a handful of possible candidates for the command position at the beginning of season 4? Well this person made that short list then, and we’re VERY excited about his/her/its(?) addition to our cast of regulars. As for who it is and what other little surprises we have in store…head on over to the SciFi site Monday morning and start refreshing.

I know for some fans, this is bad news. They may watch the show predominantly for her, but for me, it's good news. I never felt that the writers properly utilized Carter. She was a good character for the most part on SG1, yet when she came over to SGA, it was like, uh, huh? I'd honestly prefer a character/actor who can devote their time to the show, and not be off part of the season (or half, really, in this case) doing another project. 

However, on the bad side for everyone... constant cast changes. I suppose as long as the key people (Sheppard, McKay, Ronon, Teyla) stay put, I'll be pretty happy, but the constant changing of cast, pretty much for new good reason (I mean, really, did blowing up Beckett really help the show? I think not).

I'm trying to think who might be the new commander....

Mitchell? Don't think so...
Daniel? Don't think so as it's not his forte and he'd go nuts
Landry - perhaps
Caldwell - one can hope

Comments

[ellymelly.livejournal.com]

*GLARES ANGRILY AT MALLOZZI*

[alyssa22.livejournal.com]

Mallozzi's the one who needs to go. He's done nothing but stir up trouble and destroy this show since he's been in charge.

[ellymelly.livejournal.com]

i think he has written some great episodes in the past - but i was really REALLY *REALLY* starting to enjoy atlantis for the first time in AGES and then he pulls a stunt like this. honestly, I think AT could have been a major asset to the SGA team - only it seemed like half the time they were afraid to use her. Stupid stupid. GLARE GRUNT GROWL

btw. sorry wraithfodder - didn't mean to rant in you lj *hides*

[wraithfodder.livejournal.com]

Quite honestly the rants here are tame compared to the ones at GW. I think TPTB didn't utilize Carter properly in SGA. I didn't want her 'taking over' but they could have done more with the limited screentime she had, but... well, I have no idea how the guys at Bridge think.

[ellymelly.livejournal.com]

yeah, i didn't want her to take over either, but i thought effectively ignoring her was a bad move. i realise that i am heavily biased by my shipping preferences, but i thought that sam could have been show her value (at least in one ep) where she could save everybody with her genius. as much as i love mckay, it's getting old with him being the only one to technobable his way out of galactic destruction. i thought season five of sg1 had it pinned when carter and mckay went head to head on scientific issues, and you never knew which one was truely right. they didn't even touch on that at all in sga.

[wraithfodder.livejournal.com]

Quite honestly Carter seemed more a warm body to slot in. WHile I didn't want her taking over Rodney's role (he and Radek handle that well enough), I didn't want her to sit around and do nothing or be wishy-washy. That's why I'd rather they get a civilian back in charge who isn't science, isn't military, so is a new role. oh hey, like Weir! Of course, we need some writers who can write her...